Our Company

About Coastal
Shield Insurance

Your Trusted Insurance Experts in the Carolinas

Our Company

About Coastal Shield

At Coastal Shield Insurance, we provide expert guidance and a hands-on approach, ensuring every client receives personalized service and tailored coverage solutions. With nearly two decades of experience in the industry, our team understands the complexities of insurance and is dedicated to making the process straightforward and stress-free.

Founded in 2017 by Anna Brothers, who has worked in the insurance and real estate industry since 2006, our agency was built on the belief that people deserve guidance, competitive rates, and trusted expertise to protect what matters most. Based in Wilmington, North Carolina, we proudly serve clients in North Carolina, South Carolina and Florida, providing comprehensive coverage solutions with local knowledge and a commitment to client success.

We take pride in being a personable, community-driven agency. Rather than relying on automated systems, we prioritize real connections and expert guidance, ensuring our clients receive the personalized attention they deserve.

Our Mission & Vision

Mission & Vision Statement

At Coastal Shield Insurance, we believe insurance should be clear, accessible, and tailored to your needs. Our mission is to provide personalized coverage solutions that offer affordability without compromise, ensuring that every client receives expert guidance and unwavering support.

We envision a future where trust and transparency define the insurance experience. As a dedicated agency our goal is to build long-term relationships, offering reliable protection and peace of mind through exceptional service and integrity.

Our Company

Meet the Team

Our team is dedicated to making insurance a seamless and stress-free experience. Get to know the experts behind Coastal Shield Insurance:

Anna Brothers

Agency Owner/Agent

​I am the owner and active agent at Coastal Shield Insurance. Originally from the Baltimore/Annapolis area of MD, I remember touring lots of homes with my realtor father when I was little. Most kids would have been bored, but I LOVED it. I moved to NC to attend UNCW in 2000. I graduated with honors from the Cameron School of Business and started out working as a loan processor for Wachovia Mortgage. From there, I decided I would follow in my dad's footsteps, and obtained my real estate and then my brokers license in 2005. Loving real estate, but not loving an emotional sale, I gravitated towards the insurance side of things, and obtained my property, casualty, life and heath insurance licenses in 2006. I started working as an associate agent at Nationwide and after 5 years wanted to further my career and became an agent at NC Farm Bureau Insurance in 2011. After 7 years at Farm Bureau I wanted to be able to offer my clients more choices for insurance, and better premiums, so I opened Coastal Shield Insurance in 2017. I love my job and my clients, and believe that everyone should be treated with kindness and compassion, and try to instill that into my agency on a daily basis. Outside of the office, I love spending time with my husband Andrew, and our 3 children, Austin, Alexandra and Alaina. I also enjoy running, surfing, pilates, am a Reiki II trained practitioner and love coaching children in gymnastics.

Read More

Chris Stellaccio

Agent

I graduated with a B.A. from Salisbury State University in Salisbury, MD in 1998. My wife and relocated to Kure Beach in 2003 and I obtained my property & casualty license in 2006. While I don’t consider myself a typical salesperson, I find my strengths in having a firm grasp on guidelines and underwriting, which helps me quickly find the most competitive company to meet my clients needs. Outside of the office you can find me on the beach with my wife and daughter surfing, playing music or in my garage woodworking and tinkering with classic cars.

Read More

Madisyn Miller

Office Manager/Managing Agent

I was born and raised in Wilmington, North Carolina and I graduated from UNC Wilmington with my B.A in Communication Studies. After graduating I obtained my Property and Casualty License in North Carolina and began working for Coastal Shield. During my time in school I learned about digital marketing, sales, and branding. I love incorporating my knowledge of marketing and sales into Insurance and Customer Service, it makes me so happy knowing that I am helping others! During my free time I love to watch movies/tv shows, cook, go for walks outside, and be with my family. I would definitely call myself an extroverted introvert!

Read More

Nona Phelps

Agent

Meet Nóna Phelps, a loving mother of 4 children and 3 rescue dogs from Wilmington, NC. Nóna understands the value of family and exceptional customer service. Nóna is thrilled to be a Sales Agent with Coastal Shield Insurance Agency, where she can provide personalized insurance solutions to protect the needs of her clients.

Read More

Angela Pearson

Account Manager

I moved to Wilmington in 2010 from a small town near Raleigh, NC and graduated from CFCC in 2015. I obtained my insurance license in 2021 to help expand my knowledge and career in helping others. I really enjoy living in this area, spending a lot of time around Carolina Beach. My family and I live for warmer weather and summertime here in Wilmington! In my off time I’m with my husband, daughter and 2 dogs making new memories.

Read More

Michael Pajarillo

Customer Service Representative

I completed my bachelor's degree in 2001 and have been working for over 15 years in the fields of administration, office management and customer service. I joined Coastal Shield Insurance in September 2022 as a full time CSR and since then I am living the insurance life, riding the wave of learning, and loving every moment of it! I am so lucky to work with the best team in this industry! During my spare time, I am an adventurous soul, exploring different places, one destination at a time. I enjoy karaoke nights with friends and family as well as binge-watching movies and tv shows.

Read More

Mande Barden

Agent

Mande Barden, a proud Wilmington, NC native (and Tarheel), brings over 25 years of experience in the financial services industry and is now channeling her expertise into the insurance sector. Passionate about building relationships, Mande is dedicated to helping others protect what matters most and providing peace of mind through tailored insurance solutions. Outside of work, Mande enjoys spending time on the water, whether boating or relaxing at the beach, with her husband, Chris, and their son, Hayes. With a commitment to service and a personal touch, Mande is excited to help you navigate your insurance needs.

Read More

Brian Annesi

Associate Agent

I was born and raised in Northern New Jersey. After obtaining my bachelor’s degree from Montclair State University, I began my career in insurance working as a commercial general liability adjuster with Greater New York Mutual Insurance. I then transitioned into the field of property adjusting and investigations based out of Philadelphia. I moved to Wilmington in 2013 to begin a career in the golf industry. I worked in various management roles for the PGA Tour Superstores in Myrtle Beach and Orlando. I also spent three years working in sales and operations for a golf supplies distribution company in Charleston. Following my stint in the golf business I went back into claims working for Progressive auto and State Farm field property claims for the past 6 years. After working in various roles in claims departments, I decided to combine my knowledge of insurance with my customer service focus by transitioning into the agency side. I love helping people and have a passion for knowledge. Outside of the office you can find me spending time with my dog, playing golf, spending time outdoors and learning new hobbies!

Read More
Service Areas

Areas We Serve

Agency Owner/Agent

Anna Brothers

Agency Owner/Agent

​I am the owner and active agent at Coastal Shield Insurance. Originally from the Baltimore/Annapolis area of MD, I remember touring lots of homes with my realtor father when I was little. Most kids would have been bored, but I LOVED it. I moved to NC to attend UNCW in 2000. I graduated with honors from the Cameron School of Business and started out working as a loan processor for Wachovia Mortgage. From there, I decided I would follow in my dad's footsteps, and obtained my real estate and then my brokers license in 2005. Loving real estate, but not loving an emotional sale, I gravitated towards the insurance side of things, and obtained my property, casualty, life and heath insurance licenses in 2006. I started working as an associate agent at Nationwide and after 5 years wanted to further my career and became an agent at NC Farm Bureau Insurance in 2011. After 7 years at Farm Bureau I wanted to be able to offer my clients more choices for insurance, and better premiums, so I opened Coastal Shield Insurance in 2017. I love my job and my clients, and believe that everyone should be treated with kindness and compassion, and try to instill that into my agency on a daily basis. Outside of the office, I love spending time with my husband Andrew, and our 3 children, Austin, Alexandra and Alaina. I also enjoy running, surfing, pilates, am a Reiki II trained practitioner and love coaching children in gymnastics.

Agent

Chris Stellaccio

Agent

I graduated with a B.A. from Salisbury State University in Salisbury, MD in 1998. My wife and relocated to Kure Beach in 2003 and I obtained my property & casualty license in 2006. While I don’t consider myself a typical salesperson, I find my strengths in having a firm grasp on guidelines and underwriting, which helps me quickly find the most competitive company to meet my clients needs. Outside of the office you can find me on the beach with my wife and daughter surfing, playing music or in my garage woodworking and tinkering with classic cars.

Office Manager/Managing Agent

Madisyn Miller

Office Manager/Managing Agent

I was born and raised in Wilmington, North Carolina and I graduated from UNC Wilmington with my B.A in Communication Studies. After graduating I obtained my Property and Casualty License in North Carolina and began working for Coastal Shield. During my time in school I learned about digital marketing, sales, and branding. I love incorporating my knowledge of marketing and sales into Insurance and Customer Service, it makes me so happy knowing that I am helping others! During my free time I love to watch movies/tv shows, cook, go for walks outside, and be with my family. I would definitely call myself an extroverted introvert!

Agent

Nona Phelps

Agent

Meet Nóna Phelps, a loving mother of 4 children and 3 rescue dogs from Wilmington, NC. Nóna understands the value of family and exceptional customer service. Nóna is thrilled to be a Sales Agent with Coastal Shield Insurance Agency, where she can provide personalized insurance solutions to protect the needs of her clients.

Account Manager

Angela Pearson

Account Manager

I moved to Wilmington in 2010 from a small town near Raleigh, NC and graduated from CFCC in 2015. I obtained my insurance license in 2021 to help expand my knowledge and career in helping others. I really enjoy living in this area, spending a lot of time around Carolina Beach. My family and I live for warmer weather and summertime here in Wilmington! In my off time I’m with my husband, daughter and 2 dogs making new memories.

Customer Service Representative

Michael Pajarillo

Customer Service Representative

I completed my bachelor's degree in 2001 and have been working for over 15 years in the fields of administration, office management and customer service. I joined Coastal Shield Insurance in September 2022 as a full time CSR and since then I am living the insurance life, riding the wave of learning, and loving every moment of it! I am so lucky to work with the best team in this industry! During my spare time, I am an adventurous soul, exploring different places, one destination at a time. I enjoy karaoke nights with friends and family as well as binge-watching movies and tv shows.

Agent

Mande Barden

Agent

Mande Barden, a proud Wilmington, NC native (and Tarheel), brings over 25 years of experience in the financial services industry and is now channeling her expertise into the insurance sector. Passionate about building relationships, Mande is dedicated to helping others protect what matters most and providing peace of mind through tailored insurance solutions. Outside of work, Mande enjoys spending time on the water, whether boating or relaxing at the beach, with her husband, Chris, and their son, Hayes. With a commitment to service and a personal touch, Mande is excited to help you navigate your insurance needs.

Associate Agent

Brian Annesi

Associate Agent

I was born and raised in Northern New Jersey. After obtaining my bachelor’s degree from Montclair State University, I began my career in insurance working as a commercial general liability adjuster with Greater New York Mutual Insurance. I then transitioned into the field of property adjusting and investigations based out of Philadelphia. I moved to Wilmington in 2013 to begin a career in the golf industry. I worked in various management roles for the PGA Tour Superstores in Myrtle Beach and Orlando. I also spent three years working in sales and operations for a golf supplies distribution company in Charleston. Following my stint in the golf business I went back into claims working for Progressive auto and State Farm field property claims for the past 6 years. After working in various roles in claims departments, I decided to combine my knowledge of insurance with my customer service focus by transitioning into the agency side. I love helping people and have a passion for knowledge. Outside of the office you can find me spending time with my dog, playing golf, spending time outdoors and learning new hobbies!